Oscar Pistorius’s great escape from a murder verdict could be short-lived. There have been growing calls from South Africa’s top legal minds for the state to appeal against his conviction on the lesser charge of culpable homicide – a ruling that has shocked the nation and the world.

Judge Thokozile Masipa found on Friday that although the Olympic athlete had recklessly and negligently killed Reeva Steenkamp on Valentine’s Day last year, he was not guilty of the more serious charge of murder. He is scheduled to be sentenced next month.

One of the country’s leading criminal law experts, Advocate Mannie Witz, said Masipa’s judgment needed to be considered by a senior bench to provide clarity for South African courts.

“The National Prosecuting Authority doesn’t have to appeal, but in all honesty, with the eyes of the world on us and the sharp debate among the legal fraternity about her interpretations, the country deserves clarity,” Witz said. “Only the Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein can provide that.”

James Grant, professor of criminal law at the University of the Witwatersrand, said it was unlikely the NPA and prosecutor Gerrie Nel would be driven to act only by pressure from the public or from the legal fraternity.

“Having said that, Nel is under a duty to see that justice is done,” Grant said.

“The provisions of the law that allow the prosecution to appeal an error of law are clearly conceived to allow for justice to ultimately prevail. I expect Nel will take this step for these reasons, which are, in my view, the right reasons.”

They are just two voices in a growing chorus of legal commentators who have monitored the trial and the judgment and who have publicly questioned the Masipa judgment.

However, they are not in unanimous agreement on which aspect of the law they believe Masipa got wrong.

The NPA has formally stated it will announce any further legal action only after sentencing.

Subscribe to our Youtube Channel:

Robert Ngwira
Robert Ngwira
Attended Our Future Private Secondary School in Rumphi from 2006-2009 Holder of Diploma in Journalism from Malawi Institute of Journalism (MIJ) Hobbies, reading newspapers, going out with friends, listening to radio and watching football. Email: info@faceofmalawi.com


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Featured Video

click to play


More like this

Keenalf – Ifeyo (Official Music Video)

Keenalf - Ifeyo (Official Music Video)

Young Man narrates how his church didn’t support his wedding because his fiancee was from another church

Nigеrian еntrеprеnеur Nеlson Nwamara, co-foundеr of Homеland Group, rеcеntly...

A Man Who Truely Loves You Will Not Last Long In Bed – Woman Claims

Ghanaian actress and nudist, Shugatiti, sparked a conversation on...

MPS tightens security in the festive season

Malawi Police Service (MPS) has disclosed plans to tighten...